Senator Hutchinson's Handicap

Letter to the Editor - October 31, 1997

Background:

If you are a U.S. citizen and were to think up a particularly good way to keep people from snooping into your personal email messages, say by using the fifth chapter of Huckleberry Finn as an encryption key, and then were to tell a friend in Europe how to do it, you would be breaking the law. This is because the U.S. government considers large encryption keys to be munitions.

Think about this: to communicate an idea is illegal in America.

The government claims it needs access to all large encryption keys to protect against terrorists and drug dealers. The FBI is actually pushing for domestic controls on all encryption.

What I want to know is, who watches the watchmen? Anyone unable to believe that government agencies would misuse their access to private communications is apallingly ignorant of modern American history.

In this letter to the San Antonio Express-News, I take umbrage at Texas Senator Kay Bailey Hutchinson's attempt to come down on the wrong side of this argument and simultaneously pander to the pro-censorship rabble too dull-witted to realize the two issues have nothing to do with each other. Apparently, if it involves computers, it involves porn.

Kind of makes you wonder what's on Ms. Hutchinson's hard drive...

To the editors:

I was not surprised when anti-privacy Senator Kay Bailey Hutchinson voted to limit the encryption of messages on the internet, essentially denying people the right to an email "envelope".

I was alarmed, however, when I read that in dismissing fellow Republican Senator Conrad Burns' rival Pro-CODE bill (which is considerably more business-friendly), Ms. Hutchinson said, "I think Senator Burns' bill is the freest approach for us to compete on the open marketplace, but I do want to protect our children from pornography."

This statement has filled me with compassion. I had no idea that Senator Hutchinson was afflicted with the inability to distinguish one thing from another. The poor woman's daily life must be a terrifying ordeal, her muddled senses forever confusing apples with orangutans. How does she eat dinner without accidentally swallowing the salt shaker?

I have a suggestion that could help: every single object in the state should be plainly labelled with its name and function spelled out in large, colorful block letters. When confused as to an object's identity, Ms. Hutchinson could then simply read the label, thus averting possible disaster.

This would, of course, be a huge and expensive undertaking, but with enough volunteers to shoulder the burden, we can make Texas safe for everyone, even Republican senators.

Sincerely,
David Bryant

The Express-News called me to say they would be printing the letter. Unfortunately, I don't know if it ever actually made it into print. After purchasing San Antonio's sad and expensive excuse for a daily paper for almost two weeks, I finally gave up looking.

By the way, you can find Huckleberry Finn, along with a whole lot of other great books, at Project Gutenburg. It is one of hundreds of repositories of electronic texts available on the internet. Use them lawfully, citizens.


Return to the Curmudgeon Files.

© 1997, 1998 by David Bryant.
All Rights Reserved.